Holy Family, after Rembrandt; the Virgin seated with the Christ Child on her lap before a small fire with a cat beyond, in a domestic interior Black and red chalk, with grey and brown wash, touched with pen and brown ink


© The Trustees of the British Museum

  • Full: FrontFull: Front

Department: Prints & Drawings

Registration number: 1895,0915.1200

Bibliographic reference
Sumowski 1979 continuing 1790x
Hind 1915-31 5
JCR 732
Royalton-Kisch 2010 Maes.1

Dutch Roy XVIIc

Back to search results

Back to catalogue

Object types
drawing (scope note | all objects)

paper (all objects)
drawn (scope note | all objects)
Production person
Drawn by Nicolaes Maes (biographical details | all objects)
Formerly attributed to Rembrandt (biographical details | all objects)
After Rembrandt (biographical details | all objects)
1646-1650 (circa)
Schools /Styles
Dutch (scope note | all objects)

The Holy Family with the Cat, after Rembrandt; the Virgin seated with the Christ Child on her lap before a small fire with a cat beyond, in a domestic interior. c.1646-50
Red and black chalk with brown and grey wash, and pen and brown ink; ruled framing-lines in pen and brown ink.
Verso: blank (see Inscriptions).
Watermark: foolscap (indistinct), similar to Amsterdam, 1998, cat.no.245, w117, repr. p.245 (on a drawing by Pieter Molijn, probably made between 1638 and 1650)

Inscription Content: Inscribed lower right, Esdaile's mark (see Provenance); verso, in graphite, top left corner: ‘1490’; lower right: ‘14 / 6 Sheet’; lower left: ‘717 [?]’ (erased) and another inscription covered by the beginning of Esdaile's; in pen and brown ink, lower left corner: ‘14/59’ and, in Esdaile's hand: ‘1835 WE Out of the colln of Goll van Falkenstein [sic]’.*
* The numerical inscription ‘14/59’ resembles those by Valerius Röver (L.2984), but it does not relate to the manuscript inventory of his collection (see, for example, the drawing by Rembrandt of Cornelis Claesz. Anslo, cat. no.31; 1848,0911.138). According to Robinson, 1869/76, no.717/732, there was a further inscription on the verso which is no longer present: ‘The picture was formerly in the Louvre, it is now at Hesse Cassel.’.

Height: 192 millimetres (top corners cut)
Width: 287 millimetres (chain lines horizontal, 25mm apart)

Trimmed; otherwise generally good; some minor scuffs and creasing.

Curator's comments
After the 1646 painting by Rembrandt in the Staatliche Museen, Kassel (Bredius 572).

Entry from Martin Royalton-Kisch, 'Catalogue of drawings by Rembrandt and his school', 2010, Nicolaes Maes after Rembrandt, cat. no.1:
A copy by Maes after Rembrandt's painting of 1646 in Kassel.[1] Approximately one quarter of the painting, on the right, which shows a 'trompe l'oeil' curtain, and all the edges of the panel, which show a fictive frame, are omitted or were cut away when the drawing was trimmed. The top, arched section of the painting is also left out, and the bed behind Mary is not clearly discernible.
These elements do appear in a second version of the drawing, now in the Ashmolean Museum in Oxford, which is also attributed to Maes.[2] Drawn on a sheet of vellum, this is clearly an independent, finished work of art, and copies of this type appear to have been standard products of draughtsmen who were training or working in Rembrandt's studio.[3] Although the relationship between the two drawings is not entirely clear, it may be that the British Museum is a first version or sketch towards the Ashmolean Museum's more pictorially complete drawing.
The attribution to Maes seems convincing, for two main reasons. The combination of different media, and the range of touch, varying from the liquid application of washes to the almost pedantic pen lines, is found in a number of his works, including cat. nos.2 and 4 (Oo,10.121 and 1860,0616.88). Equally, the simplification of some forms into geometric, if rather rough-hewn blocks, as seen especially in the Christ child and the cat, is also characteristic of many drawings by Maes. He probably became a pupil of Rembrandt soon after the painting was made, but may have had access to the work later, in a location outside Rembrandt's studio. The date of c.1646-50 suggested here is therefore somewhat conjectural, but the careful execution, especially of the mother and child group, suggests an early date.

[1] Bredius 572.
[2] Sumowski 1791x. According to correspondence with its late owner, Karl Parker, in British Museum files, he acquired the drawing from the art-dealer, Mellaert; and Jonathan Richardson senior, who owned the drawing in the 18th century, believed it was by Rembrandt. Sumowski (loc. cit.) and Robinson, 1996 (diss.), pp.147-8, suggest that the Oxford version was perhaps based on the British Museum drawing rather than on the painting. But in view of its clear inclusion of the bed and its more accurate reflection of other elements in the oil, for example in the background immediately above the Virgin's head and in the proportions of the cat, this seems unlikely).
[3] See Corpus, III, 1989, pp.13-16.

LITERATURE (as Maes after Rembrandt's painting in Kassel unless otherwise stated):
Robinson, 1869/76, no.717/732 (see n.1 above); London, 1915, p.91, no.5; Valentiner, 1923, p.22; Valentiner, 1924, p.1, repr. fig.1 (drawn in a favoured technique for Maes); Van Dyke, 1927, pp.112 and 119 (by Van der Pluym, to whom also attributes Kassel painting); Exh. Chicago-Minneapolis-Detroit, 1969-70, p.23; Sumowski, 1979 etc., VIII, 1984, p.4026, no.1790x,repr.; Bruyn, 1988, p.328 (discussing copies after Rembrandt by Maes and other pupils); Corpus, III, 1989, p.16 and n.21 (mentions Oxford version); Robinson, 1989 (1990), p.159; Robinson, 1996 (diss.), pp.147-8 (curtain of original painting probably cut away; Oxford version perhaps based on the BM drawing rather than on the painting).

interior (scope note | all objects)
holy family (scope note | all objects)
domestic building (all objects)

Associated names
Representation of Virgin Mary (biographical details | all objects)
Representation of Jesus Christ (biographical details | all objects)

Acquisition date

Acquisition name
Purchased from Col John Wingfield Malcolm (biographical details | all objects)
Previous owner/ex-collection Johann Goll van Franckenstein (biographical details | all objects)
Previous owner/ex-collection Samuel Woodburn (his sale, Christie's, 13.vi.1860/1418 as 'Rembrandt, Van Rhyn - The Virgin and Child in a room, St J) (biographical details | all objects)
Previous owner/ex-collection John Malcolm of Poltalloch (biographical details | all objects)
Previous owner/ex-collection William Esdaile (L.1617) (biographical details | all objects)

Acquisition notes
J. Goll van Franckenstein (According to Esdaile's inscription; not, however, identifiable in Goll van Franckenstein's sale catalogue of 1833); William Esdaile (L.2617); his sale, Christie's, fifth day, 23 June, 1840, lot 1055 (as Rembrandt), bt S. Woodburn, £8-18-6; his sale, Christie's, 13.vi.1860/1418 as 'Rembrandt, Van Rhyn - The Virgin and Child in a room [...]', bt W. B. Tiffin, from whom purchased 22 March, 1866, by John Malcolm of Poltalloch for £35 (according to annotated copy of Robinson, 1876, in the British Museum); purchased with Malcolm's collection, 1895.

Exhibition History
London, 1956, p.32, no.2;
1992, BM, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle (not in catalogue);
London, 1996-7 (listed in Appendix), Malcolm Exhibition.

Noticed a mistake? Have some extra information about this object? Please contact us

To bookmark this page select "Bookmark this page" or "Add to favourites" from the web browser menu.